ACRAMENTO,
June 19 — Across the country, the cost of workers'
compensation insurance is soaring at the highest rate in nearly
a decade, adding yet another heavy burden on businesses and the
struggling national economy.
The governors of Florida, West
Virginia and Washington have called special sessions of their
Legislatures this year to find ways to contain costs, and
elsewhere, thousands of bills on workers' compensation have been
introduced.
The system covers 127 million
workers nationally but is regulated state by state, with no
federal oversight. Unlike with Medicare and Medicaid, Congress
has no role in the regulation of workers' compensation.
Nationwide, the average cost
of workers' compensation insurance has risen 50 percent in the
last three years, according to Robert P. Hartwig, the chief
economist at the Insurance Information Institute, a trade group
in New York.
But nowhere in the country
have prices been rising faster and with more debilitating impact
than here in California. The average cost of workers'
compensation insurance here has nearly doubled over the past
three years, said David Bellusci, the chief actuary of the
Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau in San Francisco,
another insurer-backed organization.
As a result, dozens of
businesses in California — big and small — have laid off
workers, according to state officials and business leaders. Some
businesses have closed and a few have moved to other states
where insurance costs have not risen as much.
Prices are escalating,
government and industry officials said, because of rising
medical and legal costs; a recent devastating price war by
insurers; and, many insurers and business executives say, a
significant amount of fraud.
In the last few years, the
cost of almost all kinds of insurance has been rising sharply.
But workers' compensation insurance, which pays for treatment of
on-the-job injuries and lost wages, is a particular problem
because its purchase is mandatory. Businesses cannot trim their
workers' compensation coverage to save money because, every
employee must be fully insured.
"The only way to reduce
your cost is to reduce your payroll," said Allan Zaremberg,
the president of the California Chamber of Commerce.
Part of the problem has been
created by the insurers and the boom-and-bust cycle of their
industry.
In the mid-90's, expenses for
workers' compensation insurers dipped and profits skyrocketed
just as the stock and bond markets were at their most exuberant.
Now, after dropping their
prices below the cost of covering claims in a fierce battle for
market share, and confronted with dismal investment returns, the
insurers are hitting their customers with astounding price
increases. The pace of the premium increases picked up after the
insurance industry lost at least $40 billion in the terrorist
attacks on Sept. 11.
Another factor pushing up
workers' compensation prices has been medical costs. While a
shift away from manufacturing jobs to less-dangerous service
work, broad improvements in safety and reductions in workers'
eligibility for benefits has led to a drop of 36 percent in
workers' compensation claims over the last decade, the average
medical cost per claim has nearly doubled, to $15,300, Mr.
Hartwig said.
In California, the average
medical cost has nearly quadrupled, to $35,201 over the past
decade, according to Mr. Bellusci.
As striking as the premiums
seem, they do not capture the depth of the problem, said John
Garamendi, the California insurance commissioner. Since taking
office in January, Mr. Garamendi said, he has yet to find a
business that is paying only the average price increases.
"I just talked to a maid
service business that said it was looking at an increase from
$20,000 to over $120,000 over a two-year period," he said.
In Los Angeles on Tuesday,
trainers at the Hollywood Park thoroughbred racetrack told the
insurance commissioner and a reporter that premiums for grooms
and exercise riders had jumped 70 percent in the last year and
had at least doubled for jockeys. Ed Halpern, the executive
director of the California Thoroughbred Trainers, said some
owners were shipping horses to racetracks in other states to
reduce costs.